Select a page

Banking News

Performance expectations get tougher for Banks downunder

Performance expectations get tougher for Banks downunder

(Australia) - In the latest release of customer satisfaction metrics across virtually all corporate banking product groups, levels of importance attached to particular product areas and relationship factors by customers are high and growing amongst Australian corporates.

Of the 26 measures taken in a 6-monthly analysis of bank performance by industry analysts East & Partners, only 2 (Commercial Paper and Short Term Domestic Debt) are rated by the markets in total as being of less importance than at June 2001 and only 5 of less than average (mid-point on the 1-5 rating scale) importance to them. Notably, debt and some of the financial markets product lines are deemed least important to the customer, whilst many of the relationship banking factors are rated as being critically important. There is of course, some correlation between these two sets of measures - service areas in which a bank is seen to be performing poorly, often attract high importance ratings for that very reason; they are problem areas for the customer.

The 5 products and/or service attributes of most importance to corporate and institutional CFOs in this March 2002 sweep are:

1 - Loyalty to the Relationship
 
2 - Understanding the Customer's Real Business Needs
- Quality of People
 
3 - Account Management
- Particular Industry Expertise
- Understanding Industry Sector
 
4 - Funds Management
 
5 - Call Money Market

Notably, of these, the 6 most important are not concerned with products; they are all concerned with the level of commitment displayed by the bank to the customer's business needs and the way(s) in which the bank endeavours to satisfy those needs.

The 5 measures seen as least important by corporate and institutions in their corporate banking "partnerships" remain equally instructive:

26 - Short Term FX Debt
 
25 - Long Term FX Debt
 
24 - Forward Rate Agreements
 
23 - Futures
 
22 - Options

Comparisons between these importance ratings and customer satisfaction assessments attached to the same products and relationship factors demonstrate that the industry is generally performing okay in those areas rated less important by customers and best in those products and service attributes seen as more important. There is major variation by individual bank in these measures however.

Market Wide Importance Ratings
  Average Rating Reported
1 — — 2 — 3 — 4 — — 5

(important)                      (unimportant)
     
  April 2002 June 2001
     
Cash Management, Debt and Bonds    
Call Money Market 1.28 1.33
Commercial Paper 1.90 1.93
Funds Management 1.24 1.28
Short Term Domestic Debt 1.48 1.44
Short Term FX Debt 3.25 3.22
Long Term Domestic Debt 1.88 1.93
Long Term FX Debt 3.06 3.12
Trade Finance 2.03 2.10
Corporate Bonds 2.13 2.21
     
Treasury and Financial Markets    
Spot FX 1.89 1.94
Forward FX 1.41 1.48
Forward Rate Agreements 2.90 2.96
Swaps 2.39 2.43
Futures 2.70 2.78
Options 2.61 2.66
     
Corporate Finance and Advisory    
Equity Raising 1.40 1.44
Particular Industry Expertise 1.20 1.22
Corporate Advisory Services 1.52 1.55
Merger and Acquisition Advice 1.88 1.94
     
Relationship Banking    
Account Management 1.20 1.22
Understanding Business Needs 1.16 1.17
Understanding Industry Sector 1.20 1.23
Innovative Solutions 1.79 1.88
Proactivity 2.07 2.12
Loyalty to the Relationship 1.14 1.18
Quality of People 1.16 1.20

 

Market Wide Satisfaction Ratings
  Average Rating Reported
1 — — 2 — 3 — 4 — — 5

(satisfied)                      (dissatisfied)
     
  April 2002 June 2001
     
Cash Management, Debt and Bonds    
Call Money Market 2.27 2.34
Commercial Paper 2.15 2.17
Funds Management 1.41 1.39
Short Term Domestic Debt 2.47 2.49
Short Term FX Debt 3.16 3.24
Long Term Domestic Debt 3.00 3.06
Long Term FX Debt 2.45 2.51
Trade Finance 2.28 2.31
Corporate Bonds 2.55 2.54
     
Treasury and Financial Markets    
Spot FX 2.00 2.04
Forward FX 1.55 1.60
Forward Rate Agreements 1.48 1.50
Swaps 2.45 2.46
Futures 2.73 2.70
Options 2.73 2.75
     
Corporate Finance and Advisory    
Equity Raising 2.97 2.97
Particular Industry Expertise 2.53 2.52
Corporate Advisory Services 2.09 2.11
Merger and Acquisition Advice 1.83 1.89
     
Relationship Banking    
Account Management 3.18 3.23
Understanding Business Needs 2.73 2.78
Understanding Industry Sector 2.88 2.90
Innovative Solutions 2.70 2.79
Proactivity 3.08 3.13
Loyalty to the Relationship 2.48 2.39
Quality of People 2.70 2.66

 

Satisfaction Ratings - Product / Service Performance
  Average Rating Reported
1 — — 2 — 3 — 4 — — 5

(satisfied)                    (dissatisfied)
     
  April 2002 June 2001
     
Cash Management, Debt and Bonds    
Call Money Market 2.14 2.22
Commercial Paper 2.05 2.07
Funds Management 1.22 1.20
Short Term Domestic Debt 2.24 2.28
Short Term FX Debt 2.96 3.04
Long Term Domestic Debt 2.79 2.88
Long Term FX Debt 2.33 2.30
Trade Finance 2.21 2.26
Corporate Bonds 2.46 2.44
     
Treasury and Financial Markets    
Spot FX 1.78 1.80
Forward FX 1.63 1.66
Forward Rate Agreements 1.33 1.38
Swaps 2.21 2.25
Futures 2.53 2.55
Options 2.48 2.57
     
Corporate Finance and Advisory    
Equity Raising 2.89 2.78
Particular Industry Expertise 2.59 2.55
Corporate Advisory Services 1.82 1.79
Merger and Acquisition Advice 1.51 1.44

 

Satisfaction Ratings - Customer Support
  Average Rating Reported
1 — — 2 — 3 — 4 — — 5

(satisfied)                     (dissatisfied)
     
  April 2002 June 2001
     
Cash Management, Debt and Bonds    
Call Money Market 2.28 2.36
Commercial Paper 2.11 2.28
Funds Management 1.36 1.38
Short Term Domestic Debt 2.53 2.55
Short Term FX Debt 3.12 3.22
Long Term Domestic Debt 2.98 3.05
Long Term FX Debt 2.42 2.55
Trade Finance 2.49 2.44
Corporate Bonds 2.60 2.65
     
Treasury and Financial Markets    
Spot FX 2.18 2.23
Forward FX 1.62 1.74
Forward Rate Agreements 1.41 1.45
Swaps 2.49 2.44
Futures 2.74 2.69
Options 2.77 2.80
     
Corporate Finance and Advisory    
Equity Raising 2.83 2.99
Particular Industry Expertise 2.61 2.68
Corporate Advisory Services 2.27 2.34
Merger and Acquisition Advice 1.71 1.89

 

Satisfaction Ratings - Value for Money
  Average Rating Reported
1 — — 2 — 3 — 4 — — 5

(satisfied)                       (dissatisfied)
     
  April 2002 June 2001
     
Cash Management, Debt and Bonds    
Call Money Market 2.39 2.44
Commercial Paper 2.29 2.15
Funds Management 1.64 1.60
Short Term Domestic Debt 2.65 2.63
Short Term FX Debt 3.40 3.45
Long Term Domestic Debt 3.23 3.26
Long Term FX Debt 2.59 2.68
Trade Finance 2.14 2.22
Corporate Bonds 2.58 2.53
     
Treasury and Financial Markets    
Spot FX 2.04 2.08
Forward FX 1.40 1.40
Forward Rate Agreements 1.69 1.66
Swaps 2.64 2.68
Futures 2.93 2.85
Options 2.95 2.88
     
Corporate Finance and Advisory    
Equity Raising 3.20 3.14
Particular Industry Expertise 2.40 2.34
Corporate Advisory Services 2.18 2.20
Merger and Acquisition Advice 2.21 2.33
East & Partners's avatar

Comment on this article

 

Your comments will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 

Please enter the word you see in the image below:


Subscribe

Subscribe to our mailing list

Sign up now to keep up-to-date with the latest
market news and insights in B2B banking.

* indicates required

For more information please read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Statements.